06 March 2009

Prop 8 unconstitutional? We'll know soon.

Yesterday, the California Supreme Court heard oral arguments on whether or not Proposition 8, the ballot measure that banned same-sex marriage in California last November, is constitutional.

The Washington Post describes the angle taken by opponents of Prop 8:
Gay rights advocates are urging the court to overturn the ban, approved in November as Proposition 8, on the grounds it was put before voters improperly, or at least prematurely. Under state law, the legislature must approve significant constitutional changes before they can go on the ballot.
Interestingly, leading the battle in favor of the discriminatory Prop 8 is Ken Starr, who, as special prosecutor a decade ago, led the investigation into Bill Clinton's private sexual business. (Gotta wonder what kinds of deeply entrenched personal issues drive Mr. Starr's obsession and judgmentalism regarding other people's sex lives.)

So will Starr succeed in this latest crusade? Will this set a precedent on which the civil rights of any group could be subject to the whim of a fired-up sanctimonious voting majority?

The Court will rule on whether or not it is constitutional. But perhaps the more important question is whether or not it is right. And discrimination never is.

2 comments:

  1. It is my honor and delight to officiate for same sex marriages in Connecticut

    I even advised all my 100 or so civil union couples that I would upgrade them to marriage for NO charge (if they came to Norwalk or Darien).

    CT is proud to lead the way to provide this basic right to ALL couples.

    CT is the ONLY state where a same sex couple can get married in one day- no residency requirement, no blood test, no witnesses. Just the $30 license fee and $10 for a certified copy plus the fee for the officiant (which varies by officiant and by location). I take care of everything for as little as $200.

    I have couples who have flown in from CA, FL, TX, IN, OH, IL, Mexico and who have driven in or taken the train from NYC, NJ, PA, RI, VA

    Most couples have been together for YEARS...including one couple from Florida who have been together for 45 years!
    Let people love each other and take care of each other. Isn't that what marriage is about?

    Mary Pugh, CT Justice of the Peace, Norwalk, CT

    www.ct-jp.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mary, thank you so much, and please keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete